Renovating an investment property takes time and money, with the ultimate goal of increasing the property value. However, there are specific renovations that yield the highest return on investment (ROI).
Before committing to major upgrades, learn about the top renovations that will boost property value and attract the right buyer or tenants.
Understanding ROI on Renovations
In real estate, ROI measures how much of a renovation’s cost is added to the property’s value.
For example, if you spend $100,000 on upgrades and the property’s value increases by $80,000, your ROI would be 80%.
Understanding this metric helps investors focus on projects that pay for themselves (or at least come close) or even exceed 100% ROI—essentially turn every dollar spent on a higher return.
Benefits of High ROI Renovations for Real Estate Investors
Investing in high-ROI renovations offers several notable advantages for real estate investors.
Here are six of the most compelling benefits:
- Maximized Resale Value: Focusing on improvements that buyers value most can significantly boost your selling price. Data suggests that a kitchen remodel can yield an ROI ranging from 56% to 100%.
- Faster Sales and Better Marketability: Homes with sought-after upgrades (modern kitchens, updated bathrooms, great curb appeal) tend to attract more buyers and sell faster.
- Increased Home Equity: Value-adding improvements raise the property’s appraised value, which builds equity. Investors can leverage this equity for future investments or refinancing.
- Higher Rental Income: Smart renovations can justify higher rents and attract quality tenants for rental properties.
- Tax Advantages: Many renovation costs on investment properties are tax-deductible or depreciable. This can improve your after-tax return on investment.
- Improved Property Condition: High-ROI projects often coincide with necessary maintenance (e.g., new roofing, updated windows). These add value, reduce future repair costs, and give buyers confidence in the home’s condition.
High-ROI Renovations: Challenges for Investors
High-ROI renovations are undoubtedly appealing, but investors also need to consider some of the potential downsides they’ll face.
Upfront Costs and Budget Overruns
Quality renovations require significant upfront capital. It’s easy to underestimate costs – a common mistake is starting a remodeling project without a buffer for unexpected expenses (uncovered structural issues, etc.).
Underestimating the budget or failing to track expenses can eat into ROI.
Over-Improvement Risks
Not every upgrade yields value; in fact, some can backfire. Spending beyond what your market supports is likely a misstep.
Over-improving is risky—if your upgrades exceed neighborhood norms, buyers may not be willing to pay extra, resulting in a poor or even a negative return on investment.
Personalized or Niche Remodels
Highly customized renovations based on personal taste can hurt resale value. An over-the-top or uniquely styled remodel might impress you, but it could decrease your home’s value if it doesn’t appeal to the average buyer.
Diminishing Returns on Upscale Projects
As a rule, minor improvements often yield a better ROI percentage than major luxury overhauls.
Investors should avoid assuming that higher spending guarantees higher returns—when it comes to remodeling for ROI, sometimes less is more.
Unknown Market Factors
ROI figures are averages; actual returns can vary with market conditions. A renovation completed during a buyer’s market (high inventory, low demand) might not add as much value as it would in a seller’s market.
Economic shifts, regional preferences, and even trends can influence what buyers value.
Market volatility means ROI is not guaranteed – investors should have a buffer and not rely solely on resale to recoup costs.
Comparing the ROI of Different Renovations
Not all renovation dollars are equal.
Below is a comparison of high-ROI renovations versus low-ROI (or riskier) renovations, illustrating which projects offer the best bang for your buck.
The data is based on numbers published by Bankrate.
| Renovation Project | Average Cost | Estimated Value Increase | ROI (%) | Notes |
| HVAC Conversion to Electric Heat Pump | $17,747 | $18,367 | 103.5% | Highest ROI; appeals to energy-conscious buyers |
| Garage Door Replacement | $4,302 | $4,420 | 102.7% | Low-cost, high-return exterior upgrade |
| Steel Front Door Replacement | $2,214 | $2,234 | 100.9% | Increases curb appeal; low investment |
| Stone Veneer Exterior | Not specified | Not specified | 102.3% | Boosts curb appeal significantly |
| Vinyl Siding Replacement | Not specified | Not specified | 94.7% | Durable, visually impactful |
| Fiber-Cement Siding Replacement | Not specified | Not specified | 88.5% | Slightly lower ROI than vinyl, but more fire-resistant |
| Minor Kitchen Remodel | $26,790 | $22,963 | 85.7% | Cosmetic upgrades; midrange materials used |
| Basement Remodel | ~$57,500 | ~$49,450 | 86% (est.) | Adds livable space without expanding footprint |
| Midrange Bathroom Remodel | $24,606 | ~$16,410 | 66.7% | Basic fixture upgrades only |
| Major Kitchen Remodel (Midrange) | $77,939 | ~$32,590 | 41.8% | Includes layout changes and high-cost materials |
| Major Kitchen Remodel (Upscale) | Up to $150,000 | ~$50,000 | 31.7% | Over-customization limits appeal to general buyers |
| Luxury Bathroom Remodel | $76,827 | ~$28,205 | 36.7% | ROI declines with highly personalized or lavish upgrades |
Choosing the Right Projects for Your Investment Properties
Are you ready to pursue high-ROI renovations? Here is a step-by-step guide to selecting and implementing the right projects:
Assess the Property and Market
Start with a thorough assessment of the property’s current condition and its position in the market.
Research comparable properties (“comps”) in the neighborhood to identify common features and understand their impact on selling prices.
Define Your Budget
Set a realistic budget for renovations aligned with your investment goals. If you are doing multiple renovations, break down the budget by project. Always include a contingency for unexpected costs (e.g., discovering old wiring that needs replacement).
Choose Your Financing Option
Decide how you will finance the project: cash savings (ideal to avoid interest) or financing through a home equity line of credit (HELOC) if needed for larger projects.
Prioritize High-ROI Projects
Based on your assessment, list potential projects and rank them by impact and ROI. Focus on the “big bang for the buck” items first— those identified in the comparative analysis as high-return.
Plan the Renovation Details
Define each chosen project’s scope and quality level to align with your budget and target ROI. Create a project timeline and sequence (e.g., do structural or exterior work first, interior cosmetic work last).
Be sure to secure the necessary permits early to avoid legal issues or costly delays.
Hire Reputable Contractors (or DIY wisely)
Solicit multiple bids from licensed contractors for each job before choosing one.
If you have the skills, some cosmetic tasks like painting, installing light fixtures, or landscaping can be DIY projects to save money, but leave complex work (electrical, plumbing, structural changes) to the professionals.
Monitor Progress and Budget
Review contractor work regularly and ensure it matches the plan. Approve change orders only if necessary.
Stay flexible—unexpected issues are common, and adjusting plans is often more effective than absorbing additional expenses.
Quality Check and Finishing Touches
Once renovations are complete, do a thorough walkthrough. Ensure all work is up to code and meets specifications. Address any contractor punch list items.
Case Studies: Renovations with the Highest Return on Investment
Here are a few real-world examples to demonstrate how high-ROI renovation strategies play out.
These scenarios are based on data published by Bankrate about the ROI of certain home renovations.
Case Study 1: Maximizing ROI in a Flip
An investor purchased a dated single-family home and focused on a few strategic upgrades.
First, they replaced the garage and front entry doors, spending about $6,800 combined. At resale, the appraised value increased by roughly $12,000, effectively recouping over 170% of those costs.
The investor opted for a minor kitchen remodel (~$25,000) instead of a full gut rehab for the property’s interior. This yielded about a 96% return (approximately $24,000 added value for $25k spent).
Case Study 2: Rental Property Value-Add
A landlord in a particularly competitive rental market wanted to increase her rental income and chose to do so by investing in renovations. She focused on energy-efficient upgrades and livability improvements she knew tenants would appreciate.
For $15,000, she replaced old windows with new double-pane energy-efficient windows, added extra insulation in the attic, and upgraded to an efficient heat pump HVAC system.
She also gave the interior a cosmetic refresh: new paint, updated light fixtures, and refinished original hardwood floors.
After these upgrades, she increased the monthly rent by 10%, and the property’s value rose by approximately $20,000—a strong ROI on the total investment.
Case Study 3: Adding Living Space Smartly
Rather than building a costly addition, an investor in a suburban home capitalized on existing square footage.
The home had an unfinished basement of about 800 sq. ft. He invested roughly $60,000 to finish the basement, turning it into a functional living area with a home office and an extra bathroom.
It sold for about $50,000 more than similar homes without finished basements, corroborating an ROI of roughly ~83% on the basement project—very close to the national average.
In Summary: Choosing Renovations with the Highest Return on Investment
For real estate investors, the central lesson is clear: choose your renovations strategically.
Successful investors treat renovation decisions with the same rigor as any financial investment: they analyze data (cost vs. value), set budgets and goals, and remain disciplined to avoid common mistakes like over-improvement or poor planning.
In summary, renovations with the highest return on investment tend to be those that marry broad buyer appeal with cost-effective upgrades—think refreshes over redos and enhancements over extravagances.
Here are three more articles packed with value for real estate investors:
- What Is Cap Rate In Real Estate? An In-Depth Look
- Emerging Trends in Real Estate in 2025
- The BRRRR Method of Real Estate Investing
